I couldn’t decide if I wanted a white chocolate or a straight-up chocolate fudge. Then it occurred to me what about an Oreo fudge? Well I don’t know if you‘ve ever been gripped with indecision, but when I am-I just go for it. I can’t say this always works out well, but in this instance it did. The Oreo gives the fudge a nice textural and flavor break from the richness of the chocolates.
Double Decker Oreo Fudge
As a chocolate lover, I’ve never been a huge fan of fudge. It’s usually too rich and I can never have more than just a few bites. But as my friend Michelle, and from a one blogger to another, she reminded me I don’t have to like it.
- Double Decker Oreo Fudge
Before you shake your head in confusion-let me say I totally agree. If you are a regular reader than you know this is the case when it comes to peanut butter. Not only do I not like it, but I’m also allergic to it. Luckily, not so much that it prevents me from working with it.
That said, I decided, yes I would make some fudge for a Valentine’s treat, since many people do love fudge and it’s fast and easy to make.
As for the result and as a non-fudge fan—I will say loved it. The Oreos really make it perfect for me.
A few notes:
- If you are not a white chocolate fan, replace that portion with all chocolate and omit the butter. The butter helps to melt and keep white chocolate smooth.
- For straight black and white double decker fudge omit the Oreo.
- Make sure to store the fudge in a tightly sealed container to keep it creamy and moist.
Double Decker Oreo Fudge
Preparation: Line a 8×8 pan with foil.
Ingredients:
- 1 can of sweetened condensed milk, portioned in half
- 10 Oreos, chopped
- 1 cup white chocolate
- 2 tablespoon butter
- 1 cup of semi-sweet chocolate
Instructions:
- Split sweetened condensed milk in half and set aside. Chop Oreos and set aside
- Place white chocolate, one ½ of sweetened condensed milk, 2 tablespoon of butter in a heat proof bowl over simmering water. Stir and mix until melted and combined. Fold in Oreos and stir to combine. Pour mixture into pan.
- Place semi-sweet chocolate and remaining half sweetened condensed milk in a heat proof bowl over simmering water. Stir and mix until melted and combined. Pour mixture on top of Oreo layer and refrigerate for 1 an hour to set.
- Remove from refrigerator and peel away foil once set. For ease of cutting make sure to clean knife between cuts to prevent sticking.
Yum, that looks fantastic! I love Oreo in basically anything, putting it in fudge is a great idea!
I love you I love you I love you!! Fudge is my all time favorite treat and so many blogs just have chocolate or peanut butter!! This is exactly what I’ve been looking for!!
This sounds awesome! Thanks!
To die for! Another creative genius bit by you that I can’t wait to try.
This looks almost too pretty to eat. Almost 🙂
What did you use to make the tops of the pieces white in your photos?
These sound amazing, and look down right stylish to boot!
Mmm! Fudge that has Oreo is my favorite kind. Thanks for sharing–even if fudge isn’t typically your favorite! 😉
Hi Jason- Since I refrigerated the fudge prior to photographing, I think the condensation from the fudge coming to room temperature caused the light to reflect and give off a white appearance.
Sinfully good and gorgeous.
This fudge looks fantastic! My boyfriend isn’t much of a sweets eater, but two of the few things he will eat are fudge and Oreos. I can’t wait to try this out on him!
Thanks for posting!
Lovely as always.
I like Oreo fudge, oh yes I do!!! My husband likes plain. This is PERFECT four us, LOL!
i am not a fudge-fan either, but these sound so good! i can’t resist oreos 🙂 beautiful fudge & photos!
Can’t decide, make ’em both!! Great solution with awesome results. These look DELICIOUS!
okay you are unreal! LOVE THESE! Putting this on my Facebook page and just pinned and tweeted them
funny……I’m not a big fan of fudge either, and I’m not quite sure why. But this sounds like one worth trying!!
Mmmm this does look good. And seems so simple too!
It must be so delicious! But not only this, you have make then with so perfect shape, they are perfect also in this!!
These are evil! How can anyone resist them (especially when you don’t have any will power, like me)?
Fudge isn’t really the first thing I think of when I want something sweet either. However, with Oreos in it, I would change my mind. The crunch of the cookie with the smoothness of the fudge would be delicious!! Another thing to add to my baking bucket list! 🙂
What a delicious fudge recipe – I love anything with oreos in it!
Wow, this looks AMAZING!
I’ve never really been a fan of fudge; I find it too rich, too.
Although, these seem great too!
Now this is a fudge I can eat!
Oreo is a great ingredient to be added to a dessert. I tried it many times on ice creams and I never get tired of the combo. I am glad to learn another recipe where I can mix the cookies. Thank you for sharing.
I love the double decker idea, so pretty!
Just one more reason to by jeans with some stretch in them 🙂
LOVE these Naomi, you’re a GENIUS!!!
These look perfect! With people like you around, I should have been smarter than to make weight loss resolutions!
Beautiful as always. I can spot one of your recipes or photos from a mile away – just perfectly beautiful. I don’t know if you ever watched The Golden Girls – but Blanche (the man crazy Golden Girl) once said about a man she had her eye on….”He fairly screams Blanche. At least, he will when I’M through with him” – your photos and recipes scream “Naomi”.
I have to agree that fudge is not for me either, but that extra Oreo layer on the bottom might convert me!
I love chocolate but, just like you, i find the fudge too much for me. I’ll have to take your word for this and make a little. Love the double color and the oreo addition.
oh yum!! Anything with white choc and oreo is DELICIOUS!
These are so pretty! My friend loves Oreos I might have to make these for her birthday!
Brilliant idea. Double the pleasure!
Love this! It looks amazing! I love white chocolate and the oreos…it’s like a cookies & cream!
These beauties almost look too good to eat! You are quite the talent in the kitchen.
just made these today! how do you get the tops so smooth?? thanks for the great recipe – I’ll be coming back for more! 🙂
Hi, just to clarify.
In your step 2, what do you mean by “Fold in Oreos”? Thank you very much for the recipe(:
I just made this for the holidays. I had to make it twice. First time I used a stick blender to chop the Oreo’s and once folded into the white chocolate – too many crumbs, didn’t look nice. And I couldn’t get the top layer to work with the 1/2 condensed milk and 1c chocolate. So ended up tossing it out.
Second attempt, I hand chopped the oreo’s, looked much better in the white chocolate. But….again, I could not get the top layer to work, I have no idea why, it just wouldn’t work. I ended up topping it with just a layer of melted chocolate – worked out beautifully.
Made this just now. White layer is perfect but top layer is too thick and rough to spread smoothly onto the white layer so ends up looking like frosting . Please tell us what you did to get that so smooth looking. Did you refrigerate the bottom layer til hardened, then smooth warm second layer over it? I had gooshy bottom coming up through the very hard to spread top. NOT pretty! Help, please!?
I love love this recipe but for some reason my white fudge layer never hardens up like the chocolate layer. It still tastes delicious. Any advice??